Ice cream cake Safeway. The perfect ice cream sandwiches are made with silky, taste-dense ice cream that’s tucked between tender, wealthy cookies that pair completely with the ice cream, permitting the flavors of each to shine.
Unfortunately, lots of the choices from the supermarket freezer case fall quick. The cookies are flavorless, or so mushy they keep on with your fingers. And ice cream that tastes like chemicals or has texture issues — it’s overly fluffy or unpleasantly icy — makes for a poor dessert.
For this style-off, we rounded up just a little little bit of all the things from the freezer part, together with the traditional chocolate-vanilla combo, in addition to some deliciously artistic options (though we saved the chocolate-dipped selection for one more day).
Here’s the scoop on the perfect — and the worst ice cream sandwiches:
CoolHaus Double Chocolate Cookie + Peanut Butter Ice Cream
Beautifully creamy toasted peanut ice cream is tucked between thick chocolate-chocolate-chip cookies, making these a stellar decide. The Los Angeles-based mostly meals truck firm makes a wild array of different flavors, too. A 54-gram serving (½ sandwich) has 219 calories, 10 g fats, 20 g sugar. $3.50 for one sandwich on sale at Safeway.
Three Twins Sea Salted Caramel Ice Cream Sandwiches
Buttery vanilla wafers filled with legit, salty caramel ice cream is a inventive and welcome twist on the basic. The Madagascar Vanilla selection, alternatively, is nice however not nice. A 90-gram sandwich has 320 calories, 20 g fats, sixteen g sugar. A field of four is $3.99 at Sprouts Market.
Klondike Oreo Sandwiches
There’s nothing elevated or gourmet about these; they’re simply flat-out good. It’s exhausting to take only one chew. The cookie has daring chocolate taste and the Oreo filling is yummy. Other Klondike sandwich flavors embrace chocolate, vanilla and Mrs. Fields. A 68-gram sandwich has 210 calories, 6 g fats, 17 g sugar. A field of four is $3 at Safeway.
365 Everyday Value Organic Mini Fudge Mint Ice Cream Sandwiches
York Patties followers have to seize a field of those. They've simply the appropriate hit of mint and chocolate, with out an excessive amount of sugar. Note that the 365 Vanilla selection delivers huge vanilla taste, however there’s treasured little chocolate within the wafer. A 45-gram serving has one hundred twenty calories, 6 g fats, eleven g sugar. A field of eight is $4.99 at Whole Foods.
Brothers Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches
Yes, these are too candy. But it’s onerous to not love the ice cream’s massive vanilla punch and the taste and texture of a Toll House-type cookie. It’s all candy, all good. A 115-gram sandwich has 340 calories 15 g fats, 35 g sugar. A field of 12 is $12.99 at Lucky.
Baskin-Robbins Peanut Butter ’N Chocolate
The chocolate cookie is simply too flaky and messy, however the creamy peanut butter ice cream is fairly improbable. Eat this one with a fork. A 60-gram serving has 190 calories, 9 g fats, thirteen g sugar. A field of four is $3.79 at Lucky.
Skinny Cow The Dynamic Duo: Vanilla and Chocolate
These is probably not as decadent as their full-fats rivals, however wealthy chocolate cookies and successful of actual vanilla and intense chocolate make them an incredible selection for weight loss plan-aware folks in search of simply somewhat splurge. A 113-gram serving has 160 calories, 3.5 g fats, 15 g sugar. A field of 6 is $3.99 on sale at Lucky.
Alden’s Organic Mint Fudge
A swirl of fudge in minty ice cream makes for a tasty chunk, however there’s a bit a lot mint, and the cookies are so gummy, they follow your fingers. The Vanilla Bean selection has the identical textural flaw. A 66-gram sandwich has 170 calories, eight g fats, sixteen g sugar. A field of four is $4.29 at Sprouts Market.
Julie’s Organic Sea Salt Caramel Ice Cream Sandwich Squares
The cookie works, and the occasional caramel chunk is Ok, however the ice cream has an unpleasant, faux fruit taste. A 42-gram sandwich has one hundred ten calories, 4.5 g fats, 10 g sugar. A field of eight is $3.99 at Sprouts Market.
So Delicious Dairy Free Almond Milk Vanilla Minis
If you’re avoiding dairy, you would possibly get pleasure from these small, candy bites. The cookie lacks chocolate taste and the “ice cream” filling is icy, however it’s a superb model for various eaters. A 38-gram sandwich has ninety calories, 3.5 g fats, 7 g sugar. A field of eight is $5.99 at Whole Foods.
Julie’s Gluten-Free Organic Vanilla Sandwich Cookies
The hassle is commendable, however the outstanding sugar taste within the ice cream and the grainy texture of the cookie make this a poor decide. A 74-gram sandwich has 220 calories, eleven g fats, 19 g sugar. A field of four is $5.49 at Whole Foods.
Fat Boy Premium Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwich
The tremendous-thick layer of ice cream might look promising, however neither the fluffy, marshmallowlike ice cream nor the mushy cookie has a lot taste. An 86-gram serving has 210 calories, eight g fats, 17 g sugar. A field of 6 is $4.99 at Lucky.
Lucerne Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream Sandwiches
This confection appears scrumptious, however the sticky cookie has no chocolate taste, and the ice cream tastes like cotton. A 56-gram sandwich has a hundred and fifty calories, 5 g fats, thirteen g sugar. A field of 6 is $2.99 at Safeway.
Sunnyside Farms Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream Sandwiches
If you're craving straight sugar with a success of chemicals, that is it. A 60-gram serving has 160 calories, 6 g fats, thirteen g sugar. A field of 6 is $2.35 at Lucky.
- Best Review Of Klondike Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich
- Delicious Homemade Oreo Ice Cream Cake Recipe
- Oreo Ice Cream Cake Ingredients For Cookies, Cheesecake Flavors Recipes
Reviews are based mostly on product samples bought by this newspaper or offered by manufacturers. Contact Jolene Thym at firstname.lastname@example.org. Read extra Taste-off columns at www.mercurynews.com/tag/style-off.